ISFDB banner

Canceled/Rejected Publication Update Submission

You are not logged in. If you create a free account and sign in, you will be able to customize what is displayed.

Cancellation/Rejection Reason: needs to be "Paul Orban (in error)" and varianted per standards; I will make the changes

Note: For "Edit" submissions, the "Current" column shows the data as it currently exists in the database, not as it existed when the submission was created.

Field Current Pub Record #58755 Proposed Changes
Title If, July 1954 -
Transliterated Titles - -
Authors James L. Quinn -
Date 1954-07-00 -
Pub. Type MAGAZINE -
Publisher Quinn Publishing Company, Inc.; Buffalo, NY -
Pages 124 -
Format digest -
ISBN - -
Catalog ID - -
Price $0.35 -
Pub. Series - -
Pub. Series # - -
Image Image
[http://www.isfdb.org/wiki/images/6/62/WOFIFJUL1954.jpg]
ISFDB Wiki page for this image
-
Web Pages https://archive.org/details/1954-07_IF -
Note
  • Vol 3, No 5. Cover title "The Old Spaceman's Tales" as noted on the Contents/copyright page (scanned version from archive.org).
  • The full text and images of this edition are available at The Internet Archive, see web page for link.
  • "Fair and Warmer" illustration is credited as "Paul Orban" on story title page but it is signed "Freas" in lower right on illustration.
-
External IDs - -

Modified Regular Titles

Title #719129 Proposed Value Warnings
Title Fair and Warmer -  
Authors Paul Orban (in error) Kelly Freas Kelly Freas is an alternate name
Date 1954-07-00 -  
Type INTERIORART -  
Length - -  
Page 80 -  

WARNING: This publication has been verified against the primary source.

Primary Verifications

Verifier Date Type Last User Activity Date
Swfritter 2008-03-28 16:22:15 Permanent 2024-04-05

Secondary Verifications

Source Status Verifier Date
Miller/Contento Verified SGale 2015-12-15 08:59:14

WARNING: This publication has been modified by the following submissions since this submission was created:

Note to Moderator:

The magazine says the illustrator is Paul Orban but they made a mistake. The style is that of Kelly Freas and his signature is clearly visible in the lower right hand corner of page 80.

View the submission as raw XML

Submitted by Sanjo on 2021-11-12 14:16:08

Rejected by JLaTondre on 2021-11-21 12:44:45

Copyright © 1995-2024 Al von Ruff and the ISFDB team
ISFDB Engine - Version 4.00 (2006-04-24)