ISFDB Top 100 Anth/Coll/Mag (Critical List)

  1 7114 The Best of the Nebulas (1989)
             Ben Bova
  2 5575 The New Hugo Winners, Volume III (1994)
             Connie Willis+Martin H. Greenberg
  3 4821 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Sixth Annual Collection (1989)
             Gardner Dozois
  4 4672 The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume IV (1986)
             Terry Carr
  5 4562 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twelfth Annual Collection (1995)
             Gardner Dozois
  6 4562 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Twelfth Annual Collection (1995)
             Gardner Dozois
  7 4424 The Science Fiction Hall of Fame Volume Four (1981)
             Arthur C. Clarke
  8 4424 The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume III (1982)
             Arthur C. Clarke+Geo W. Proctor
  9 4402 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Fifth Annual Collection (1988)
             Gardner Dozois
 10 4124 The New Hugo Winners (1989)
             Isaac Asimov+Martin H. Greenberg
 11 4011 The New Hugo Winners, Volume IV (1997)
             Gregory Benford
 12 3967 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Third Annual Collection (1986)
             Gardner Dozois
 13 3967 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Third Annual Collection (1986)
             Gardner Dozois
 14 3957 Norton Book of SF (1993)
             Ursula K. Le Guin+Brian Attebery
 15 3945 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Eleventh Annual Collection (1994)
             Gardner Dozois
 16 3869 The Science Fiction Century (1997)
             David G. Hartwell
 17 3806 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Eighth Annual Collection (1991)
             Gardner Dozois
 18 3806 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Eighth Annual Collection (1991)
             Gardner Dozois
 19 3788 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Fourteenth Annual Collection (1997)
             Gardner Dozois
 20 3774 Future on Ice (1998)
             Orson Scott Card
 21 3460 Modern Classics of Fantasy (1997)
             Gardner Dozois
 22 3433 Nebula Awards 30 (1996)
             Pamela Sargent
 23 3419 Nebula Awards 20 (1985)
             George Zebrowski
 24 3415 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Seventh Annual Collection (1990)
             Gardner Dozois
 25 3415 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Seventh Annual Collection (1990)
             Gardner Dozois
 26 3415 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Second Annual Collection (1985)
             Gardner Dozois
 27 3339 The Hugo Winners, Volume 5 (1986)
             Isaac Asimov
 28 3331 The Year's Best Science Fiction: First Annual Collection (1984)
             Gardner Dozois
 29 3317 Best SF of the Year 14 (1985)
             Terry Carr
 30 3313 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Thirteenth Annual Collection (1996)
             Gardner Dozois
 31 3313 The Year's Best Science Fiction, Thirteenth Annual Collection (1996)
             Gardner Dozois
 32 3241 The Best from Fantasy & Science Fiction: A 40th Anniversary Anthology (1989)
             Edward L. Ferman
 33 3225 The Hugo Winners, Volume 3 (1977)
             Isaac Asimov
 34 3225 The Hugo Winners (Volume 3) (1977)
             Isaac Asimov
 35 3192 Nebula Awards 29 (1995)
             Pamela Sargent
 36 3123 The Best Fantasy Stories from the Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction (1985)
             Edward L. Ferman
 37 3061 The Hugo Winners, Volumes One and Two (1972)
             Isaac Asimov
 38 2869 The New Hugo Winners, Volume II (1991)
             Isaac Asimov+Martin H. Greenberg
 39 2838 The Arbor House Treasury of Modern Science Fiction (1980)
             Robert Silverberg+Martin H. Greenberg
 40 2838 Great Science Fiction of the 20th Century (1987)
             Robert Silverberg+Martin H. Greenberg
 41 2838 Arbor House Treasury of Modern SF (1980)
             Robert Silverberg+Martin H. Greenberg
 42 2801 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Tenth Annual Collection (1993)
             Gardner Dozois
 43 2765 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Fifteenth Annual Collection (1998)
             Gardner Dozois
 44 2728 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Sixteenth Annual Collection (1999)
             Gardner Dozois
 45 2694 Impossible Things (1993)
             Connie Willis
 46 2661 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Seventeenth Annual Collection (2000)
             Gardner Dozois
 47 2637 The Ascent of Wonder: The Evolution of Hard SF (1994)
             David G. Hartwell+Kathryn Cramer
 48 2634 Nebula Awards 22 (1988)
             George Zebrowski
 49 2611 The Hugo Winners, Volume 2 (1971)
             Isaac Asimov
 50 2564 Stories of Your Life and Others (2002)
             Ted Chiang
 51 2534 Nebula Awards 33 (1999)
             Connie Willis
 52 2523 Future on Fire (1991)
             Orson Scott Card
 53 2494 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Ninth Annual Collection (1992)
             Gardner Dozois
 54 2482 The Best from Orbit (1975)
             Damon Knight
 55 2482 Best from Orbit (1975)
             Damon Knight
 56 2475 Nebula Awards 31 (1997)
             Pamela Sargent
 57 2448 Nebula Award Stories 8 (1973)
             Isaac Asimov
 58 2418 Nebula Awards 25 (1991)
             Michael Bishop
 59 2382 Best SF of the Year 11 (1982)
             Terry Carr
 60 2354 The Year's Best Science Fiction: Eighteenth Annual Collection (2001)
             Gardner Dozois
 61 2354 Nebula Awards 24 (1990)
             Michael Bishop
 62 2352 Nebula Awards 21 (1986)
             George Zebrowski
 63 2327 Nebula Award Stories 17 (1983)
             Joe Haldeman
 64 2301 The Hugo Winners, Volume 4 (1985)
             Isaac Asimov
 65 2295 The Jaguar Hunter (1987)
             Lucius Shepard
 66 2266 The Fantasy Hall of Fame (1998)
             Robert Silverberg+Martin H. Greenberg
 67 2263 The Nebula Awards #18 (1983)
             Robert Silverberg
 68 2263 Nebula Awards 18 (1983)
             Robert Silverberg
 69 2215 Paragons: Twelve Master Science Fiction Writers Ply Their Craft (1996)
             Robin S. Wilson
 70 2185 Nebula Awards 19 (1984)
             Marta Randall
 71 2180 The Road to Science Fiction #3 (1979)
             James E. Gunn
 72 2174 Modern Classic Short Novels of Science Fiction (1994)
             Gardner Dozois
 73 2171 Think Like a Dinosaur and Other Stories (1997)
             James Patrick Kelly
 74 2159 Best SF of the Year 10 (1981)
             Terry Carr
 75 2142 1985 Annual World's Best SF (1985)
             Donald A. Wollheim
 76 2133 Nebula Award Stories 7 (1973)
             Lloyd Biggle, Jr.
 77 2118 The Road to Science Fiction #4 (1982)
             James E. Gunn
 78 2104 The Super Hugos (1992)
             Isaac Asimov
 79 2101 World's Best SF 1988 (1988)
             Donald A. Wollheim
 80 2080 Geodesic Dreams (1992)
             Gardner Dozois
 81 2066 Best SF of the Year 12 (1983)
             Terry Carr
 82 2053 Best Science Fiction & Fantasy of the Year #16 (1987)
             Terry Carr
 83 1995 An Alien Land (1998)
             Mike Resnick
 84 1980 Asimov's Science Fiction, Nov 1994 (1994)
             Gardner Dozois
 85 1958 Her Smoke Rose Up Forever (1990)
             James Tiptree, Jr.
 86 1955 Nebula Awards 32 (1998)
             Jack Dann
 87 1918 World's Best SF 1966 (1966)
             Donald A. Wollheim+Terry Carr
 88 1915 The 1989 Annual World's Best SF (1989)
             Donald A. Wollheim+Arthur W. Saha
 89 1880 Best SF of the Year 5 (1976)
             Terry Carr
 90 1849 Nebula Winners 15 (1981)
             Frank Herbert
 91 1846 Best SF of the Year 13 (1984)
             Terry Carr
 92 1815 Nebula Award Stories 9 (1974)
             Kate Wilhelm
 93 1798 Nebula Award Stories 6 (1971)
             Clifford D. Simak
 94 1784 Best Science Fiction Stories of the Year (1979) (1980)
             Gardner Dozois
 95 1784 Best SF Stories of the Year: Ninth Annual Collection (1980)
             Gardner Dozois
 96 1779 The Reel Stuff (1998)
             Martin H. Greenberg+Brian Thomsen
 97 1776 Best Science Fiction Stories of the Year (1980) (1981)
             Gardner Dozois
 98 1773 The 1980 Annual World's Best SF (1980)
             Donald A. Wollheim+Arthur W. Saha
 99 1766 World's Best SF 1987 (1987)
             Donald A. Wollheim
100 1765 Nebula Winners 12 (1978)
             Gordon R. Dickson