- Award Category: Amateur Publication Award Category Record # 103
- Award Type: Balrog Award
| 1979 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Win | Shayol | Pat Cadigan and Arnie Fenner |
| Nomination | Dragonbane | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy Newsletter | Paul C. Allen |
| Nomination | Whispers | Stuart David Schiff |
| 1980 | ||
| Win | Fantasy Newsletter | Paul C. Allen |
| Nomination | Eldritch Tales | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Night Voyages | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Pandora | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Robert E. Howard United Press Association | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Shayol | Pat Cadigan and Arnie Fenner |
| Nomination | Space & Time | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Weirdbook | W. Paul Ganley |
| Nomination | Whispers | Stuart David Schiff |
| 1981 | ||
| Win | Fantasy Newsletter | Paul C. Allen |
| Nomination | Dragon Fields | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Eldritch Tales | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy Tales | Stephen Jones and David Sutton |
| Nomination | Locus | Charles N. Brown |
| Nomination | Lovecraft Studies | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Rehupa | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Science Fiction Review | Richard E. Geis |
| Nomination | Shayol | Pat Cadigan and Arnie Fenner |
| Nomination | Space & Time | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Weird Tales Collector | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Weirdbook | W. Paul Ganley |
| Nomination | Whispers | Stuart David Schiff |
| 1982 | ||
| Win | Eldritch Tales | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy Newsletter | Paul C. Allen and Robert A. Collins |
| Nomination | Fantasy Tales | Stephen Jones and David Sutton |
| Nomination | Kadath | Francesco Cova |
| Nomination | Night Voyages | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Shayol | Pat Cadigan and Arnie Fenner |
| Nomination | Space & Time | Unknown-Mags |
| 1983 | ||
| Win | Shayol | Pat Cadigan and Arnie Fenner |
| Nomination | Eldritch Tales | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Fantasy Newsletter | Robert A. Collins |
| Nomination | Locus | Charles N. Brown |
| Nomination | Psycho II | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Science Fiction Chronicle - 1982 | Andrew Porter |
| Nomination | Space & Time | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Weirdbook | W. Paul Ganley |
| Nomination | Well of the Souls | Unknown-Mags |
| Nomination | Whispers | Stuart David Schiff |
| 1984 | ||
| Win | Fantasy Newsletter/Fantasy Review | Robert A. Collins |
| 1985 | ||
| Win | Eldritch Tales | Crispin Burnham |