- Award Category: Best Film Award Category Record # 298
- Award Type: International Horror Guild Award
| 1994 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Win | Interview with the Vampire (IMDB) | Anne Rice |
| 1995 | ||
| Win | The Lord of Illusions (IMDB) | Clive Barker |
| 1996 | ||
| Win | Scream (IMDB) | Kevin Williamson |
| Nomination | From Dusk Till Dawn (IMDB) | Robert Kurtzman and Quentin Tarantino |
| Nomination | Se7en (IMDB) | Andrew Kevin Walker |
| Nomination | The Crow: City of Angels (IMDB) | David S. Goyer and James O'Barr |
| Nomination | The Frighteners (IMDB) | Peter Jackson and Frances Walsh |
| 1997 | ||
| Win | No Award | - |
| 1998 | ||
| Win | Gods and Monsters (IMDB) | Bill Condon and Christopher Bram |
| Nomination | Apt Pupil (IMDB) | Brandon Boyce and Stephen King |
| Nomination | Dark City (IMDB) | Alex Proyas and Lem Dobbs and David S. Goyer |
| Nomination | Fallen (IMDB) | Nicholas Kazan |
| Nomination | John Carpenter's Vampires (IMDB) | Don Jakoby and John Steakley and Dan Mazur |
| 1999 | ||
| Win | Stir of Echoes (IMDB) | David Koepp and Richard Matheson |
| Nomination | Sleepy Hollow (IMDB) | Kevin Yagher and Andrew Kevin Walker and Washington Irving |
| Nomination | The Blair Witch Project (IMDB) | Daniel Myrick and Eduardo Sanchez |
| Nomination | The Sixth Sense (IMDB) | M. Night Shyamalan |
| Nomination | The Talented Mr. Ripley (IMDB) | Anthony Minghella and Patricia Highsmith |
| 2000 | ||
| Win | American Psycho (IMDB) | Mary Herron and Guinevere Turner |
| Win | Shadow of the Vampire (IMDB) | Steven Katz |
| Nomination | Pitch Black (IMDB) | Ken Wheat and Jim Wheat and David Twohy |
| Nomination | Requiem for a Dream (IMDB) | Hubert Selby, Jr. and Darren Aronofsky |
| Nomination | The Cell (IMDB) | Mark Protosevich |
| Nomination | Unbreakable (IMDB) | M. Night Shyamalan |
| 2001 | ||
| Win | Ginger Snaps (IMDB) | John Fawcett and Karen Walton |
| Nomination | Espinazo del Diablo,El (The Devil's Backbone) (IMDB) | Guillermo del Toro and Antonio Trashorras and David Muõz |
| Nomination | From Hell (IMDB) | Alan Moore and Eddie Campbell and Terry Hayes and Rafael Yglesias |
| Nomination | Jeepers Creepers (IMDB) | Victor Salva |
| Nomination | Le Pacte Des Loups (Brotherhood of the Wolf) (IMDB) | Stéphane Cabel and Christophe Gans |
| Nomination | The Others (IMDB) | Alejandro Amenábar |
| 2002 | ||
| Win | Frailty (IMDB) | Bill Paxton and Brent Hanley |
| Nomination | One Hour Photo (IMDB) | Mark Romanek |
| Nomination | Sen to Chihiro no kamikakushi / Spirited Away (IMDB) | Hayao Miyazaki and Cindy Davis Hewitt and Donald H. Hewitt |
| Nomination | The Ring (IMDB) | Gore Verbinski and Kôji Suzuki and Hiroshi Takahashi and Ehren Kruger |
| Nomination | Wendigo (IMDB) | Larry Fessenden |