- Award Category: Best Graphic Story Award Category Record # 302
- Award Type: International Horror Guild Award
| 1996 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Win | Hellboy: Wake the Devil | Mike Mignola |
| Nomination | Atomic Chili: The Illustrated Joe Lansdale | Joe R. Lansdale |
| Nomination | Preacher: Gone to Texas | ??? Ennis and ??? Dillon |
| Nomination | Starman: Sins of the Fathers | ??? Robinson and ???,von Growbager,??? Harris |
| Nomination | Superman Returns | ??? Jurgens |
| 1997 | ||
| Win | Preacher: Proud Americans | Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon |
| Nomination | Black Hole | Charles Burns |
| Nomination | Essential Swamp Things | Jennifer Lee |
| 1998 | ||
| Win | Transmetropolitan: Back on the Street | Warren Ellis and Darick Robertson |
| Nomination | Blood for the Muse: Agony, Ecstasy, Tragedy | Terry M. West and Stew Noak and Glenn Chadbourne and Ryan Dunleavy |
| Nomination | Cages | Dave McKean |
| Nomination | Night City #1 | Mort Castle and Don Kramer and Mark Nelson and Jaewon |
| Nomination | Preacher: Ancient History | Garth Ennis and Richard Case |