ISFDB banner

Award Category: Best Editor, Short Form (Retro Hugo Award)

You are not logged in. If you create a free account and sign in, you will be able to customize what is displayed.

Displaying all wins and nominations for this category. You can also limit the list to the wins in this category.

2014
1 ---- John W. Campbell, Jr.
2 ---- Farnsworth Wright
3 ---- Raymond A. Palmer
4 ---- Mort Weisinger
5 ---- Walter H. Gillings
--- Nominations Below Cutoff -------
* ---- T. O'Conor Sloane
2016
1 ---- John W. Campbell
2 ---- Frederik Pohl
3 ---- Dorothy McIlwraith
4 ---- Raymond A. Palmer
5 ---- Mort Weisinger
--- Nominations Below Cutoff -------
* ---- Martin Goodman
* ---- Charles D. Hornig
* ---- Mary Gnaedinger
* ---- Farnsworth Wright
* ---- Malcolm Reiss
2018
1 ---- John W. Campbell
2 ---- Donald A. Wollheim
3 ---- Dorothy McIlwraith
4 ---- Raymond A. Palmer
5 ---- Oscar J. Friend
6 ---- Malcolm Reiss
2019
1
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Runoff
John W. Campbell 250 355
Donald A. Wollheim 89
Dorothy McIlwraith 48
Mary Gnaedinger 30
No Award 15 24
Oscar J. Friend 5
Raymond A. Palmer 3
45 nominations with 31.25 final points.
 ---- John W. Campbell
2
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1
Donald A. Wollheim 198
Dorothy McIlwraith 66
Mary Gnaedinger 46
No Award 19
Raymond A. Palmer 17
Oscar J. Friend 9
12 nominations with 4.5 final points.
 ---- Donald A. Wollheim
3
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2 Pass 3 Pass 4
Dorothy McIlwraith 87 91 93 115
Mary Gnaedinger 60 68 69 80
Raymond A. Palmer 56 59 60
No Award 24 25
Oscar J. Friend 23
25 nominations with 9 final points.
 ---- Dorothy McIlwraith
4
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2
Mary Gnaedinger 112 114
Raymond A. Palmer 66 68
Oscar J. Friend 31 31
No Award 24
14 nominations with 4.67 final points.
 ---- Mary Gnaedinger
5
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1
Raymond A. Palmer 97
Oscar J. Friend 55
No Award 31
12 nominations with 2.92 final points.
 ---- Raymond A. Palmer
6
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1
Oscar J. Friend 110
No Award 33
7 nominations with 2.08 final points.
 ---- Oscar J. Friend
--- Nominations Below Cutoff -------
*
ⓘ3 nominations with 0.65 final points
 ---- Alden H. Norton
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 1 final point
 ---- Farnsworth Wright
*
ⓘ2 nominations with 0.5 final points
 ---- W. Scott Peacock
*
ⓘ2 nominations with 0.4 final points
 ---- Robert A. W. Lowndes
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.2 final points
 ---- Malcolm Reiss
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.2 final points
 ---- Frank A. Munsey
*
ⓘ3 nominations with 1.58 final points
 ---- Frederik Pohl
2020
1
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Runoff
John W. Campbell 151 193
Dorothy McIlwraith 52
Mary Gnaedinger 39
No Award 18 39
Raymond A. Palmer 12
Oscar J. Friend 2
W. Scott Peacock 1
33 nominations with 23.92 final points.
 ---- John W. Campbell, Jr.
2
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2 Pass 3 Pass 4 Pass 5
Dorothy McIlwraith 78 79 80 90 91
Mary Gnaedinger 50 51 58 63 64
No Award 30 30 30 33
Raymond A. Palmer 30 30 30
Oscar J. Friend 11 11
W. Scott Peacock 2
14 nominations with 4.45 final points.
 ---- Dorothy McIlwraith
3
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2 Pass 3
Mary Gnaedinger 89 92 101
Raymond A. Palmer 47 50 54
No Award 30 30 30
Oscar J. Friend 16 16
W. Scott Peacock 7
6 nominations with 1.82 final points.
 ---- Mary Gnaedinger
4
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2 Pass 3
Raymond A. Palmer 69 76 105
No Award 38 38 41
Oscar J. Friend 33 38
W. Scott Peacock 17
11 nominations with 2.78 final points.
 ---- Raymond A. Palmer
5
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1 Pass 2
Oscar J. Friend 56 79
No Award 41 41
W. Scott Peacock 30
8 nominations with 1.78 final points.
 ---- Oscar J. Friend
6
ⓘ
Finalist Pass 1
W. Scott Peacock 74
No Award 42
7 nominations with 1.58 final points.
 ---- W. Scott Peacock
--- Nominations Below Cutoff -------
*
ⓘ2 nominations with 0.67 final points
 ---- Babette Rosmond
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 1.00 final point
 ---- Donald A. Wollheim
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.25 final points
 ---- Bernard G. Davis
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.25 final points
 ---- Frederik Pohl
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.20 final points
 ---- Sam Moskowitz
*
ⓘ1 nomination with 0.20 final points
 ---- William de Grouchy
Copyright © 1995-2024 Al von Ruff and the ISFDB team
ISFDB Engine - Version 4.00 (2006-04-24)