- Award Category: Best Critic (old) Award Category Record # 340
- Award Type: Locus Poll Award
| 1974 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ---- | Richard E. Geis |
| 2 | ---- | P. Schuyler Miller |
| 2 | ---- | Joanna Russ |
| 4 | ---- | Theodore Sturgeon |
| 5 | ---- | Brian W. Aldiss |
| 6 | ---- | Alexei Panshin and Cory Panshin |
| 7 | ---- | Lester del Rey |
| 8 | ---- | Richard A. Lupoff |
| 9 | ---- | David G. Hartwell |
| 10 | ---- | James Blish |
| 11 | ---- | Charles N. Brown |
| 12 | ---- | Harlan Ellison |
| 13 | ---- | Richard Delap |
| 14 | ---- | Buck Coulson |
| 15 | ---- | Cy Chauvin |
| 15 | ---- | Anthony R. Lewis |