Place |
Year and Award |
Title |
Category |
12
|
1973 Locus
|
|
Best Fan Writer (old) |
9
|
1974 Locus
|
|
Best Critic (old) |
8
|
1975 Locus
|
|
Best Critic (old) |
7
|
1978 Locus
|
Cosmos
|
Best Magazine |
Nomination
|
1981 Balrog
|
for editing at Gregg Press, Pocket Books, and Simon & Schuster
|
Professional Achievement |
Nomination
|
1981 World Fantasy
|
Pocket/Timescape/Simon&Schuster
|
Special Award, Professional |
Nomination
|
1982 World Fantasy
|
Timescape
|
Special Award, Professional |
5
|
1982 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Nomination
|
1983 World Fantasy
|
Timescape
|
Special Award, Professional |
5
|
1983 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Win
|
1984 SF Chronicle
|
Timescape Books
|
Editor (Books) |
Win
|
1984 SF Chronicle
|
|
Editor (Books) |
Win
|
1984 SF Chronicle
|
|
Most Attractive Male Editor |
2
|
1984 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
6
|
1985 Locus
|
Age of Wonders: Exploring the World of Science Fiction
|
Best Non-Fiction/Reference |
Nomination
|
1985 SF Chronicle
|
Timescape/Tor/Arbor House
|
Editor (Books) |
Nomination
|
1986 SF Chronicle
|
Tor Books, Arbor House
|
Pro Editor - Books |
Nomination
|
1987 World Fantasy
|
Arbor House
|
Special Award, Professional |
Win
|
1987 SF Chronicle
|
Arbor House, Tor Books
|
Pro Editor - Books |
3
|
1987 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Win
|
1988 World Fantasy
|
Arbor House/Tor/Anthologies
|
Special Award, Professional |
Win
|
1988 World Fantasy
|
The Dark Descent
|
Best Anthology |
6
|
1988 Locus
|
The Dark Descent
|
Best Anthology |
Win
|
1988 SF Chronicle
|
|
Pro Editor - Books |
2
|
1988 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
18
|
1989 Locus
|
Masterpieces of Fantasy and Enchantment
|
Best Anthology |
14
|
1989 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
3
|
1989 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1988
|
Best Semiprozine |
2
|
1989 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
3
|
1989 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Win
|
1989 SF Chronicle
|
William Morrow
|
Pro Editor - Books |
10
|
1990 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
1990 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1989
|
Best Semiprozine |
11
|
1990 Locus
|
The World Treasury of Science Fiction
|
Best Anthology |
Nomination
|
1990 SF Chronicle
|
|
Pro Editor - Books |
3
|
1990 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
4
|
1990 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
13
|
1991 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
1991 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1990
|
Best Semiprozine |
7
|
1991 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
13
|
1992 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine/Fanzine |
5
|
1992 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1991
|
Best Semiprozine |
Nomination
|
1992 SF Chronicle
|
|
Pro Editor - Books |
7
|
1992 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
10
|
1993 Locus
|
Foundations of Fear
|
Best Anthology |
Nomination
|
1993 SF Chronicle
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Semi-Prozine |
14
|
1993 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine/Fanzine |
4
|
1993 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1992
|
Best Semiprozine |
Nomination
|
1993 SF Chronicle
|
|
Pro Editor - Books |
5
|
1993 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Honorable Mentions
|
1993 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Nomination
|
1994 World Fantasy
|
Christmas Forever
|
Best Anthology |
10
|
1994 Locus
|
Christmas Forever
|
Best Anthology |
13
|
1994 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
1994 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1993
|
Best Semiprozine |
5
|
1994 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Honorable Mentions
|
1994 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Nomination
|
1995 Aurora
|
Northern Stars: The Anthology of Canadian Science Fiction
|
Best Other Work in English / Meilleur ouvrage en anglais (Autre) |
9
|
1995 Locus
|
Northern Stars: The Anthology of Canadian Science Fiction
|
Best Anthology |
3
|
1995 Locus
|
The Ascent of Wonder: The Evolution of Hard SF
|
Best Anthology |
11
|
1995 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
1995 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1994
|
Best Semiprozine |
Win
|
1995 SF Chronicle
|
Tor Books, various anthologies
|
Pro Editor - Books |
4
|
1995 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
1995 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
10
|
1996 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
1996 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1995
|
Best Semiprozine |
Win
|
1996 SF Chronicle
|
Tor Books, various anthologies
|
Pro Editor - Books |
6
|
1996 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
1996 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
3
|
1997 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1996
|
Best Semiprozine |
Nomination
|
1997 SF Chronicle
|
Tor Books
|
Pro Editor - Books |
4
|
1997 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
1997 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
7
|
1997 Locus
|
Visions of Wonder: The Science Fiction Research Association Anthology
|
Best Anthology |
3
|
1997 Locus
|
Year's Best SF
|
Best Anthology |
7
|
1998 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
2
|
1998 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1997
|
Best Semiprozine |
4
|
1998 Locus
|
The Science Fiction Century
|
Best Anthology |
Win
|
1998 SF Chronicle
|
Tor Books, various anthologies
|
Pro Editor - Books |
2
|
1998 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
3
|
1998 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
3
|
1998 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 2
|
Best Anthology |
7
|
1999 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
3
|
1999 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1998
|
Best Semiprozine |
2
|
1999 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
3
|
1999 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
4
|
1999 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 3
|
Best Anthology |
Nomination
|
2000 Ditmar
|
Centaurus: The Best of Australian Science Fiction
|
Best Collected Work |
13
|
2000 Locus
|
Centaurus: The Best of Australian Science Fiction
|
Best Anthology |
16
|
2000 Locus
|
Northern Suns
|
Best Anthology |
7
|
2000 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
2000 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 1999
|
Best Semiprozine |
2
|
2000 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
3
|
2000 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
3
|
2000 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 4
|
Best Anthology |
6
|
2001 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
2001 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2000
|
Best Semiprozine |
4
|
2001 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
4
|
2001 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
3
|
2001 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 5
|
Best Anthology |
8
|
2002 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
3
|
2002 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2001
|
Best Semiprozine |
4
|
2002 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2002 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
7
|
2002 Locus
|
Year's Best Fantasy
|
Best Anthology |
5
|
2002 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 6
|
Best Anthology |
2
|
2003 Locus
|
The Hard SF Renaissance
|
Best Anthology |
9
|
2003 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
3
|
2003 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2002
|
Best Semiprozine |
2
|
2003 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
4
|
2003 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
10
|
2003 Locus
|
Year's Best Fantasy 2
|
Best Anthology |
7
|
2003 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 7
|
Best Anthology |
12
|
2004 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction
|
Best Magazine |
2
|
2004 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2003
|
Best Semiprozine |
3
|
2004 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
4
|
2004 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
17
|
2004 Locus
|
Year's Best Fantasy 3
|
Best Anthology |
6
|
2004 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 8
|
Best Anthology |
4
|
2005 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2004
|
Best Semiprozine |
3
|
2005 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
2
|
2006 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2005
|
Best Semiprozine |
1
|
2006 Hugo
|
|
Best Professional Editor |
Win
|
2006 Skylark
|
|
Edward E. Smith Memorial Award for Imaginative Fiction |
3
|
2007 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2006
|
Best Semiprozine |
2
|
2007 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
5
|
2007 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Short Form |
3
|
2008 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2007
|
Best Semiprozine |
1
|
2008 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
2
|
2009 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2008
|
Best Semiprozine |
8
|
2009 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2008
|
Best Magazine |
1
|
2009 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
4
|
2009 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
23
|
2009 Locus
|
Year's Best Fantasy 8
|
Best Anthology |
12
|
2009 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 13
|
Best Anthology |
11
|
2010 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2009
|
Best Magazine |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2010 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2009
|
Best Semiprozine |
5
|
2010 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2010 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Short Form |
19
|
2010 Locus
|
Year's Best Fantasy 9
|
Best Anthology |
16
|
2010 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 14
|
Best Anthology |
14
|
2011 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2010
|
Best Magazine |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2011 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2010
|
Best Semiprozine |
4
|
2011 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Withdrawn -- Nomination Declined
|
2011 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
9
|
2011 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 15
|
Best Anthology |
5
|
2012 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2011
|
Best Semiprozine |
11
|
2012 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2011
|
Best Magazine |
4
|
2012 Locus
|
Tor.com - 2011
|
Best Magazine |
6
|
2012 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2012 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
11
|
2012 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 16
|
Best Anthology |
12
|
2013 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2012
|
Best Magazine |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2013 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2012
|
Best Semiprozine |
17
|
2013 Locus
|
The Sword & Sorcery Anthology
|
Best Anthology |
3
|
2013 Locus
|
Tor.com - 2012
|
Best Magazine |
6
|
2013 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2013 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
6
|
2013 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 17
|
Best Anthology |
16
|
2014 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2013
|
Best Magazine |
Nominations Below Cutoff ⓘ21 nominations
|
2014 Hugo
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2013
|
Best Semiprozine |
9
|
2014 Locus
|
Twenty-First Century Science Fiction
|
Best Anthology |
6
|
2014 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff ⓘ36 nominations
|
2014 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
14
|
2014 Locus
|
Year's Best SF 18
|
Best Anthology |
18
|
2015 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2014
|
Best Magazine |
1
|
2015 Locus
|
Tor.com - 2014
|
Best Magazine |
9
|
2015 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2015 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
19
|
2016 Locus
|
The New York Review of Science Fiction - 2015
|
Best Magazine |
2
|
2016 Locus
|
Tor.com - 2015
|
Best Magazine |
1
|
2016 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |
Win
|
2016 World Fantasy
|
|
Life Achievement |
Nominations Below Cutoff
|
2016 Hugo
|
|
Best Editor Long Form |
1
|
2017 Locus
|
Tor.com - 2016
|
Best Magazine |
Win
|
2017 BFA
|
Tor.com - 2016
|
Best Magazine/Periodical |
12
|
2017 Locus
|
|
Best Editor |