Title: Pebble in the Sky

Title: Pebble in the Sky Title Record # 1406
Author: Isaac Asimov
Date: 1950-00-00
Type: NOVEL
Series: Trantorian Empire
Series Number: 1
Webpages: Wikipedia-EN
Language: English

Synopsis: One man, Schwartz, suddenly travels from our time to a distant future, where Earth is a minor part of a galactic empire. Because he doesn't understand the language, he undergoes treatment to become a faster learner. A second man, Shekt, is the inventor of said treatment. He is suspected to be part of a rebellion against the empire. A third man, Arvardan, is a visiting archaeologist, trying to prove that human life originated on Earth. Their paths cross, and they are in part connected by a woman, daughter of one, love interest of the other. They need to figure out and stop a plot.

User Rating: 7.89 (9 votes) Your vote: Not cast VOTE
Current Tags: Dimension X (1), science fiction (1), Chicago (1), enhanced intelligence (1), time travel (1), into-radio (1), chess (1), rebellion (1), 1950 (1) Add Tags

Other Titles

Translations

Serializations

Translated Serializations

Year	Language	Title
1952^ⓘTranslated by Hugo Mark	Dutch	Tussen twee voetstappen
1953^ⓘTranslated by Amélie Audiberti	French	Cailloux dans le ciel
1956^ⓘTranslated by A. Maldonado Domingues	Portuguese	Futuro do Mundo
1958^ⓘTranslated by Eduardo Goligorsky	Spanish	Un guijarro en el cielo
1960^ⓘTranslated by Iris Foerster and Rolf H. Foerster	German	Radioaktiv ... !
1972^ⓘTranslated by Ugo Malaguti	Italian	Paria dei cieli
1974^ⓘTranslated by Michel Deutsch	French	Cailloux dans le ciel
1981^ⓘTranslated by Maria-Ana Tupan	Romanian	O piatră pe cer^?O piatra pe cer
1983^ⓘTranslated by Agatha Maria Auersperg	Portuguese	827 Era Galáctica
1983^ⓘTranslated by Aslı Kayabal	Turkish	Uğursuz Gezegen Galactica^?Ugursuz Gezegen Galactica
1985^ⓘTranslated by Sem Schlumper	Italian	Paria dei cieli
1987^ⓘ Translated by Ognjen Bogdanović	Serbian	Kamičak na nebu^?Kamicak na nebu Kamichak na nebu [as by Isak Asimov]
1987^ⓘ Translated by Valdislav Matović	Serbian	Šljunak na nebu
1988^ⓘTranslated by Giuseppe Lippi	Italian	Paria dei cieli
1992^ⓘTranslated by Füssi-Nagy Géza	Hungarian	Kavics az égben^?Kavics az egben
1997^ⓘTranslated by Irene Holicki	German	Ein Sandkorn am Himmel
2006^ⓘTranslated by 葉李華 (叶李华，Yeh Lee-hwa)	Chinese	蒼穹一粟^?Cāng Qióng Yí Sù [as by 艾西莫夫]
2014^ⓘA most popular Simplified Chinese version of Pebble in the Sky in China. In China, readers commonly see 1 Robot collection (I, Robot), 4 "Elijah Baley / R. Daneel Olivaw" Robot Novels, 7 Foundation Novels and Trantorian Empire Trilogy as a whole "Galactic Empire" Series (15 books). "银河帝国15"means the 15th book of the "Galactic Empire" Series. "苍穹一粟" means Pebble in the Sky. Translated by 叶李华 (Yeh Lee-hwa) into Traditional Chinese. Data from publisher's website.	Chinese	银河帝国15：苍穹一粟^?Yín Hé Dì Guó 15：Cāng Qióng Yí Sù
2016^ⓘTranslated by Aline Storto Pereira	Portuguese	Pedra no céu

Year	Title
1950	Pebble in the Sky (Complete Novel)

Year	Language	Title
1953^ⓘTranslated by Sem Schlumper	Italian	Pària dei cieli (Complete Novel)

Awards

Place	Year and Award	Category
2	2001 Retro Hugo	Best Novel

Publications

Not displaying translations • Display all variants and translations • Do not display variants or translations

Title	Date	Author/Editor	Publisher/Pub. Series	ISBN/Catalog ID	Price	Pages	Format	Type	Cover Artist
Bland Beginning, Pebble in the Sky, Just for the Bride, The Owl and the Pussycat	1950-00-00	uncredited	Unicorn Press			236, 223, 222, 240	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni
Pebble in the Sky	1950-01-19	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday (Doubleday Science Fiction)		$2.50^?$: US dollar	223	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel	Richard Powers
Two Complete Science-Adventure Books, Winter 1950	1950-12-00	ed. Jerome Bixby	Wings Publishing Co, Inc.		$0.25^?$: US dollar	148	pulp^?Magazine using the common pulp size: 6.5" by 9.5". For ISFDB purposes this may also be used as a designation for the quality of the paper. There are some untrimmed pulps that are as large as 8" by 11.75	mag	Allen Anderson
Pebble in the Sky	1951-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday (Young Moderns)		$1.00^?$: US dollar	223	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel	Richard Powers
Pebble in the Sky	1953-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Galaxy Publishing Corp. (Galaxy Science Fiction Novel #14)	14	$0.35^?$: US dollar	153	digest^?Digest-size magazine, including both standard digest size, at about 7" by 4.5", and also large digest, such as recent issues of Asimov's, which are about 8.25" by 5.125".	novel	Richard Powers
Pebble in the Sky	1957-08-00	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	A1646	$0.35^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1957-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday / SFBC			223	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel	Richard Powers
Pebble in the Sky	1958-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Corgi Books / Transworld Publishers	S583	2/6^?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling. Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g. 3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters of a shilling).	220	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	John Richards
Triangle	1961-05-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday / SFBC		$1.20^?$: US dollar	516	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	Alex Gotfryd
Triangle	1961-06-02	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday		$4.95^?$: US dollar	516	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	Alex Gotfryd
Triangle	1961-06-02	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday		C$4.50^?C$: Canadian dollar	516	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	Alex Gotfryd
Pebble in the Sky	1964-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Pathfinder	EP47	$0.45^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1964-10-00	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	EP47	$0.45^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1968-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Sidgwick & Jackson	0-283-98013-3	18/-^?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling. Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g. 3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters of a shilling).	200	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1968-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	FP47	$0.50^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1969-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere	12416	5/-^?Prior to decimilisation (1968-1971), UK books were priced in shillings, or shillings and pence, where 20 shillings equals one pound and 12 old pence equals one shilling. Shillings were indicated with a variety of suffixes, e.g. 3s, 3', 3", 3/ all mean 3 shillings. Any number after that is additional pence, usually 6 (half a shilling) but sometimes 3 or 9 (a quarter of a shilling or three-quarters of a shilling).	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
An Isaac Asimov Second Omnibus	1969-10-00	Isaac Asimov	Sidgwick & Jackson	0-283-98072-9	£2.25^?£: UK pound	516	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni
Pebble in the Sky	1971-05-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere		£0.25^?£: UK pound	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1971-06-00	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	T1567	$0.75^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Pebble in the Sky	1974-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere	0-7221-1259-9	£0.65^?£: UK pound	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Peter Elson
Pebble in the Sky	1974-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere	0-7221-1240-8	£0.35^?£: UK pound	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Eddie Jones
Pebble in the Sky	1976-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	Q2828	$1.50^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Pebble in the Sky	1977-07-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere	0-7221-1259-9	£0.65^?£: UK pound	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1978-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Sphere	0-7221-1264-5	£0.85^?£: UK pound	186	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Peter Elson
The Far Ends of Time and Earth	1979-01-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday	0-385-13269-7	$12.95^?$: US dollar	xiv+ 538	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	Robert Korn
The Far Ends of Time and Earth	1979-03-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday & Company / SFBC	5578	$4.50^?$: US dollar	xiv+ 526	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	Robert Korn
Pebble in the Sky	1980-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	0-449-23423-1	$1.95^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Science Fiction Special 43	1982-02-00	uncredited	Sidgwick & Jackson (Science Fiction Special #43)	0-283-98814-2	£^?£: UK pound	200+ 317	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni
Pebble in the Sky	1983-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-31196-5	$2.95^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1983-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-31196-5	C$3.75^?C$: Canadian dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1984-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-31196-5	$2.95^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1985-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-33563-5	$3.50^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1986-00-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-33563-5	$3.95^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1986-09-00	Isaac Asimov	Grafton	0-246-12919-0	£9.95^?£: UK pound	226	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1987-06-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-33563-5	$3.50^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1987-09-00	Isaac Asimov	Grafton	0-586-06952-6	£2.95^?£: UK pound	226	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Chris Foss
Pebble in the Sky	1989-06-00	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey / Ballantine	0-345-33563-5	$3.95^?$: US dollar	231	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Darrell K. Sweet
Pebble in the Sky	1990-02-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday	0-385-41269-X	$45.00^?$: US dollar	223	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	1991-09-00	Isaac Asimov	Doubleday (The Isaac Asimov Collection)	0-385-41953-8	$12.95^?$: US dollar	223	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel	Steve Youll
Pebble in the Sky	1992-01-00	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Spectra	0-553-29342-7	$4.99^?$: US dollar	309	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Steve Youll
Pebble in the Sky	1993-08-00	Isaac Asimov	HarperCollins (UK)	0-586-06952-6	£4.99^?£: UK pound	226	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	John Harris
The Empire Novels	2002-11-00	Isaac Asimov	Science Fiction Book Club	0-7394-3105-6 / 54892	$14.99^?$: US dollar	548	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	omni	John Berkey
Pebble in the Sky	2008-01-00	Isaac Asimov	Tor	978-0-7653-1912-8	$24.95^?$: US dollar	255	hc^?Hardcover. Used for all hardbacks of any size.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2009-02-01	Isaac Asimov	Blackstone Audiobooks				digital audio download^?Digital recording in any format that is downloaded directly from the Internet. This category includes podcasts.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2010-04-27	Isaac Asimov	Tor	978-1-4299-6819-5	$9.99^?$: US dollar		ebook^?Used for all electronic formats, including but not limited to EPUB, eReader, HTML, iBook, Mobipocket, and PDF.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2010-05-00	Isaac Asimov	Orb	978-0-7653-1913-5	$14.99^?$: US dollar	255	tp^?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2019-08-08	Isaac Asimov	Harper Voyager (UK)	978-0-00-837235-4	£8.99^?£: UK pound	224	tp^?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2020-09-01	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey	978-0-593-16004-6	$17.00^?$: US dollar	256	tp^?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2020-09-01	Isaac Asimov	Del Rey	978-0-593-16008-4	$11.99^?$: US dollar		ebook^?Used for all electronic formats, including but not limited to EPUB, eReader, HTML, iBook, Mobipocket, and PDF.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	2020-09-01	Isaac Asimov	Random House Audio	978-0-593-34596-2	$28.00^?$: US dollar		digital audio download^?Digital recording in any format that is downloaded directly from the Internet. This category includes podcasts.	novel
Isaac Asimov: Five Masterworks of Science Fiction	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	E371	$4.75^?$: US dollar	192, 191, 191, 223, 178	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	omni	Charles Moll
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	Q2828	$0.45^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	M1855	$0.95^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	0-449-23423-1	$1.75^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	FP47	$0.50^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	FP47	$0.50^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Books	013		200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Fawcett Crest	P2372	$1.25^?$: US dollar	191	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Paul Lehr
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Grafton	0-586-06952-6	£3.50^?£: UK pound	226	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	Chris Foss
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Bantam Pathfinder	HP4380	$0.60^?$: US dollar	200	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	HarperCollins (UK)	0-586-06952-6	£4.99^?£: UK pound	226	pb^?Paperback. Typically 7" by 4.25" (18 cm by 11 cm) or smaller, though trimming errors can cause them to sometimes be slightly (less than 1/4 extra inch) taller or wider/deeper.	novel	John Harris
Pebble in the Sky	date unknown	Isaac Asimov	Orb	978-0-7653-1913-5	$16.99^?$: US dollar	255	tp^?Trade paperback. Any softcover book which is at least 7.25" (or 19 cm) tall, or at least 4.5" (11.5 cm) wide/deep.	novel

View all covers for Pebble in the Sky (logged in users can change User Preferences to always display covers on this page)

Reviews

Review by John Carnell [as by E. J. Carnell] (1950) in Operation Fantast, #6, September 1950, (1950)
Review by uncredited (1950) in Weird Tales, May 1950 , reprinted in:
Weird Tales (2012)
Review by Frederik Pohl (1950) in Super Science Stories, May 1950
Review by The Editor (1950) in Thrilling Wonder Stories, June 1950
Review by L. Sprague de Camp (1950) in Astounding Science Fiction, August 1950
Review by uncredited (1950) in Fantasy Book, Vol. 2, No. 1
Review by Joseph H. Crawford, Jr. and James J. Donahue and Donald M. Grant (1953) in '333': A Bibliography of the Science-Fantasy Novel , reprinted in:
'333': A Bibliography of the Science-Fantasy Novel (1953)
Review [French] by Michel Jeury (1975) in Fiction, #256
Review [Dutch] by Annemarie van Ewijck [as by Annemarie Kindt] (1978) in Holland-SF 1978, #2
Review by W. Moon (1979) in Australian SF News, March 1979
Review by Terry Broome (1986) in Vector 135
Review by Andy Sawyer (1988) in Paperback Inferno, #70
Review by Peter Heck (2008) in Asimov's Science Fiction, March 2008
Review by Chris Moriarty (2008) in The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, August 2008
Review by Donald M. Hassler (2009) in The New York Review of Science Fiction, February 2009
Review [French] by Philippe Boulier (2012) in Bifrost, #66
Review [Portuguese] by Daniel Borba (2014) in Somnium, Novembro 2014