Canceled/Rejected Publication Update Submission

Cancellation/Rejection Reason: verified pub, we don't credit department editors

Note: For "Edit" submissions, the "Current" column shows the data as it currently exists in the database, not as it existed when the submission was created.

Field	Current Pub Record #999601	Proposed Changes
Title	Worlds of If, February 2024	-
Transliterated Titles	-	-
Authors	Justin T. O'Conor Sloane Jean-Paul L. Garnier	Justin T. O'Conor Sloane Jean-Paul L. Garnier Daniel Pomarède^?Daniel Pomarede Robert Silverberg
Date	2024-02-00	-
Pub. Type	MAGAZINE	-
Publisher	Starship Sloane Publishing	-
Pages	84	-
Format	digest	-
ISBN	9798988634218	-
Catalog ID	-	-
Price	$9.99	-
Pub. Series	-	-
Pub. Series #	-	-
Image	[https://isfdb.org/wiki/images/4/49/WRLDSFFMLZ2024.jpg]	-
Web Pages	https://worldsofifmagazine.com/	-
Note	Stated as vol. 1, no. 1, but also as (whole) issue #177. The page count begins on the first interior page (the inner front cover is blank). The editors are credited on the copyright page (p. 2) as follows: Justin T. O'Conor Sloane, Editor-in-Chief; Jean-Paul L. Garnier, Deputy Editor-in-Chief; Dr. Daniel Pomarède, Science Editor; Robert Silverberg, Contributing Editor. The editorials beginning respectively on pp. 2 & 6 emphasize that Sloane and Garnier did edit this issue in partnership (though with somewhat different preferences); the format is given as 'digest' within Sloane's editorial. The table of contents and the copyright section are printed on page 1. The cover art is credited within the table of contents and is titled 'Tau Zero'. The gallery of drawings by Pennington on pp. 53-59 features works that were previously unpublished in print — with the exception of the first. Pp. 8, 35, 60, 70 and 76-78 are pure ad pages (there are some more smaller sized ads); p. 79 is blank and p. 80 has the printing statement (PV1's copy was printed in France by Amazon). P. 81 (the inner back cover) again is blank; Andrew Stewart's artwork "Outland" graces the back cover (page 82 by numbering, but p. 84 within the overall page count). The ISSN 2996-0916 (for the print publication) is printed on the cover and appears in the copyright section on p. 1. The design and layout are credited to F. J. Bergmann. There's no price statement to be found within this issue (it was taken for this entry from Amazon.com).	-
External IDs	ASIN: B0CW3LM95L AU BR CA CN DE ES FR IN IT JP MX NL TR UAE UK US (US/UK earn commissions)	-

Modified Regular Titles

	Title #3292544	Proposed Value	Warnings
Title	Worlds of If - 2024	-
Authors	Jean-Paul L. Garnier+Justin T. O'Conor Sloane	Justin T. O'Conor Sloane+Jean-Paul L. Garnier+ Daniel Pomarède^?Daniel Pomarede +Robert Silverberg
Date	2024-00-00	-
Type	EDITOR	-
Length	-	-
Page	-	-

WARNING: This publication has been verified against the primary source.

Primary Verifications

Verifier	Date	Type	Last User Activity Date
Stonecreek	2024-04-03 12:28:05	Permanent	2024-05-21

WARNING: The following pending submissions also aim to change this record:

Note to Moderator:

Hahaha! This is a new one! So whoever wrote the notes here thought it was a good idea to use the editorial instead of the masthead and publishing company information to arrive at the conclusion that this was some sort of partnership and then put the chief editor's name second?! My reading of the magazine would not lead me to make a bizarre decision like that. Bad form ISFDB. Seems like your volunteer is using excessive notes to justify a very bad call. Too many cooks in the ISFDB kitchen it would seem! If you are going to break all-known conventions, then we really should add all of the editors. That's only fair. But make sure you keep the chain of command in place. Sheriff > deputy sheriff > desk sergeant > armory sergeant. There you go.

View the submission as raw XML

Submitted by SirReginaldvonderPasta on 2024-04-09 23:01:42

Rejected by JLaTondre on 2024-04-10 20:10:59